--- phase: 06.3-cycle-4-gap-closure verified_at: 2026-05-14 operator: decidel verdict: not-approved next_phase: 06.4 deploy_sha: not-deployed-local-head-fa8789f staging_url: https://rebno-staging.fly.dev/ --- # Phase 06.3 - Verification **Verdict: NOT APPROVED.** All 06.3 implementation plans have local code/test evidence, but the required staging deploy, staging Playwright gate, operator UAT, and CLI-08 milestone mp4 were not completed in this execution pass. ## GREEN Gate Status - [ ] HARD gate 1: all cli-08-* + camera-follow Playwright GREEN on staging - [ ] HARD gate 2: operator HUMAN-UAT checklist complete - [x] HARD gate 3: scoped e2e assertion canonical-ref audit for 06.3-modified specs - [ ] SOFT gate 4: staging redeploy + 5-test smoke complete ## Gate Notes HARD gate 1 was not run against staging. A local attempt was made with: ```text pnpm --filter @rebno/client test:e2e -- --grep "(cli-08|camera-follow)" --project=chromium ``` Result: blocked before tests. Playwright waited for `http://localhost:2567/health` and timed out after 60 seconds. Running the server entry directly via `pnpm --filter @rebno/server exec tsx src/index.ts` printed only the optional env-file notice and exited, so the local Playwright webServer path did not bind the health endpoint during this pass. HARD gate 2 was not run. No operator staging UAT verdict was received. HARD gate 3 was completed manually for the e2e specs modified during 06.3: - `cli-08-nameplate-offset.e2e.test.ts` - PASS, expected offset cites legacy Draw.dnd + descender compensation. - `cli-08-floor-collision.e2e.test.ts` - PASS after adding a SOURCE comment for the movement assertion; boundary constants cite NAVI_MASK and mvp-room dimensions. - `cli-08-dup-login.e2e.test.ts` - PASS, expected duplicate-login behavior cites 2026-05-13 operator decision and GameScene eviction path. SOFT gate 4 was not run. No staging redeploy or 5-step smoke evidence was captured. ## Per-Finding Closure | Finding | Status | Plan(s) | |---------|--------|---------| | D-40 residual | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-01, 06.3-10 | | D-45 Plan A offset | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-08 | | D-45 Plan B flicker | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-02, 06.3-11 | | D-45 Plan C depth | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-07, 06.3-12 | | D-51 dup-login | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-03, 06.3-13 | | D-52 diagnostic | carry; diagnostics added only | 06.3-04 | | D-53 spawn delay reinit | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-05, 06.3-16 | | D-54 NAVI_MASK | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-01, 06.3-09 | | D-55 teleport anim | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-06, 06.3-17 | | D-56 chat readability | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-18 | | D-57 micro-freeze | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-04, 06.3-14 | | D-58 idle desync | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-15 | | D-59 font race | implemented; staging UAT pending | 06.3-19 | ## CLI-08 Milestone mp4 Deferred. `06.3-CLI-08-milestone.mp4` was not captured because operator UAT did not reach APPROVED. ## Automated Results - `pnpm --filter @rebno/client test --run` - PASS, 26 test files passed, 193 tests passed, 4 todo. - `pnpm --filter @rebno/client typecheck` - PASS. - `pnpm --filter @rebno/server test` - PASS, 11 test files passed, 61 tests passed. - `pnpm --filter @rebno/server typecheck` - PASS. - `pnpm --filter @rebno/game-logic test --run` - PASS, 10 test files passed, 50 tests passed. - `pnpm --filter @rebno/game-logic typecheck` - PASS. - `pnpm trace:check` - FAIL, 109 existing findings across incomplete future requirements and pre-existing tag parse/placeholder issues. Phase-relevant IDs REQ-CLI-04, REQ-CLI-06, REQ-CLI-07, REQ-CLI-08, REQ-SRV-03, and REQ-SRV-14 show required stages satisfied in the command output. ## Operator Approval NOT APPROVED - Phase 06.3 cannot close as accepted until staging deploy, staging Playwright, operator UAT, and milestone mp4 are completed. --- *Verified locally on 2026-05-14. Staging approval pending.*