--- phase: 06.2-gap-closure-d-50-d-53-uat-2026-05-13 verified_at: 2026-05-13 operator: decidel verdict: not-approved next_phase: 06.3 deploy_sha: 688d334 staging_url: https://rebno-staging.fly.dev/ --- # Phase 06.2 — Verification (cycle-4 UAT, 2026-05-13) > Cycle-4 operator UAT of staging build `688d334` (W1 spike + 6 W2 fixes merged > after cycle-3 findings). **Verdict: NOT APPROVED.** Three cycle-3 fixes > regressed, one fix invisible to operator, one new visual class (collision > grid extent), plus two new findings (teleport anim, chat readability). > Findings carry to Phase 06.3. ## Per-test results | Test ID | Description | Result | Note | | ------- | -------------------------------------------- | :----: | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | 1 | Alpha-keyed sprites (D-39 carry) | N/A | Not re-verified — no Phase 06.2 changes to alpha pipeline | | 2.1 | Ghost player after logout (D-50) | PASS | Disappears ~10-15 s after tab close (matches onLeave grace window contract) | | 2.2 | Floor tiles + TSides visible (D-40) | PART | Tiles render in a region but only LEFT EDGE blocks player; gray border tiles outside region; other edges either don't stop player or stop at wrong point — see D-40-FAIL | | 2.3 | Background animation | PASS | No regression | | 2.4 | Duplicate-account login refused (D-51) | FAIL | Login PERMITTED. Game freezes + WS-disconnect on BOTH tabs. Tab close → no auto-reconnect. Refresh after → floor tiles gone — see D-51-REG | | 2.5 | Local sprite animates under WASD (D-41) | PASS | Run frames cycle correctly | | 2.6 | Position resets to spawn (D-52) | PASS | No resets observed during UAT — D-52 remains spike-only carry per CONTEXT §D-52 | | 2.7 | Chat round-trip | PASS | But chat box is very small / hard to read — see D-56-NEW | | 3 | Anim rate local + remote | PASS | Both 30 Hz consistent | | 4 | Nameplate Y offset (D-45) | FAIL | Overshot — nameplates now TOO HIGH. Remote nameplates flicker vertically during movement. Depth wrong — overlapped by player sprites and floor tiles — see D-45-REG | | 5 | Walkable-edge block + bg | FAIL | See 2.2 — only left edge of tiled region blocks; collision grid extent mismatches visible floor extent | | D-53 | Spawn-in 1 s hold visible | FAIL | Not observed operator-visible — spawnDelayTicks counter may not be initializing on operator flow path — see D-53-REG | ## D-52 follow-up data No D-52 reproductions during 2026-05-13 cycle-4 UAT. Diagnostic surface (`window.__rebno.lastReconcileX/Y/Reason/Seq/At` from 06.2-03) remains live on staging. Carry to Phase 06.3 sub-task — operator captures a snap-back episode and reads literal. ## Playwright e2e gates | Gate | Result | Note | | ------------------------------------------ | :----: | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | cli-08-nameplate-offset.e2e | PASS | Asserts current (overshot) Y offset — gate caught nothing because expectation matches code | | cli-08-local-anim.e2e | FAIL | 1 distinct frame observed (all NaviStandD); D-53 spawn delay overlapped 1 s sample window — fix wait-1200 ms pushed at `b34e053`, awaiting redeploy | | cli-08-floor-collision.e2e | FAIL | finalY > 850 px after KeyS hold — confirms 2.2 visual issue; collision grid extent doesn't match render extent | | camera-follow.e2e (pre-existing) | FAIL | Camera scroll flat — cascade of frozen sprite during spawn delay window | | cli-08-camera.e2e (Wave 4 carry) | FAIL | Same cascade as camera-follow | | cli-08-anim.e2e (Wave 4 carry) | FAIL | Same D-53 boundary issue as cli-08-local-anim | ## Phase 06.2 finding closure | Finding | Status | Carry plan | Reference | | ------- | ---------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | | D-40 | partial — H1 fix landed | Server room_layout delivers `tiles[]` on join (06.2-05). But collision grid extent + gray-border tiles outside region carry as D-54 to 06.3 | [06.2-05-SUMMARY](./06.2-05-SUMMARY.md) | | D-41 | closed | Axis-held wiring landed (06.2-06); cycle-4 UAT confirms run frames cycle | [06.2-06-SUMMARY](./06.2-06-SUMMARY.md) | | D-45 | regressed — overshot | Y offset overshot, remote vertical flicker, depth z-order wrong — carry to 06.3 | [06.2-07-SUMMARY](./06.2-07-SUMMARY.md) | | D-50 | closed | BL-05 evict on persist failure landed (06.2-08); cycle-4 UAT confirms ghost cleanup in 10-15 s | [06.2-08-SUMMARY](./06.2-08-SUMMARY.md) | | D-51 | regressed — both-tabs crash | Replace-session evict broke onJoin path for the new session — eviction-state delete also kills the surviving session — carry to 06.3 | [06.2-09-SUMMARY](./06.2-09-SUMMARY.md) | | D-52 | spike-only, deferred | Diagnostics live; no reproductions during cycle-4 UAT — operator capture pending in 06.3 | [06.2-03-SUMMARY](./06.2-03-SUMMARY.md) | | D-53 | not-visible regression | spawnDelayTicks landed in code (06.2-10) but no operator-visible 1 s hold — investigate gate condition + verify telemetry on `window.__rebno` | [06.2-10-SUMMARY](./06.2-10-SUMMARY.md) | | D-54-NEW | partial-floor + bad collision | Collision grid extent mismatches visible floor extent; gray-border tiles render outside region. Investigate room_layout collision payload | NEW | | D-55-NEW | teleport in/out anim missing | Legacy BNO had spawn/leave teleport anim — currently absent. Plan 7 candidate; flag for 06.3 scope discussion | NEW | | D-56-NEW | chat box readability | Chat input + history font + height too small to read comfortably. Quick UI polish in 06.3 or defer | NEW | | D-57-NEW | client movement micro-freeze + jump | Local sprite movement (not anim) freezes every few seconds then jumps to new position ~500-1000 ms later. Likely periodic reconciler snap (related-but-distinct from D-52 perfect-spawn-reset). Read `window.__rebno.lastReconcileReason` + `lastReconcileSeq` at each freeze in 06.3 | NEW | ## Operator approval **NOT APPROVED.** Phase 06.2 closes with verdict `uat-fail` per plan 06.2-11 task-2 resume-signal. Three cycle-3 fixes regressed (D-45/D-51/D-53), one new collision-extent class (D-54), two new findings (D-55/D-56). D-40 partial (H1 server payload landed but collision extent + outer gray tiles outstanding). D-52 carries spike-only. Phase 06.3 gap-closure to address: D-54 collision extent, D-45 overshoot/flicker/depth, D-51 eviction crash, D-53 visibility, plus operator capture of D-52 reproduction, plus scoping discussion for D-55 (teleport anim) and D-56 (chat readability). CLI-08 milestone video DEFERRED to Phase 06.3 close. --- *Verified by decidel on 2026-05-13. staging build `688d334`. Cycle-4 of CLI-08 milestone gate.*