--- phase: 10-cutover-cleanup wave: 7 verified: 2026-05-10T00:00:00Z status: passed score: 7/7 must-haves verified overrides_applied: 0 --- # Phase 10 / Wave 7 (10-07) Verification Report **Phase Goal:** Real-hardware UAT regimen D-25(1)..(15) executed on Bigscreen Beyond + Win11 Pro rig with operator sign-off; CLAUDE.md updated to reflect post-cutover defaults; gap closure (UX-FAIL-PILL-EARLY-RETURN) shipped; NO post-UAT default-OFF restore. **Verified:** 2026-05-10 **Status:** passed (agent-scope per sign-off block; physical-only operator items explicitly out of agent scope per the user's request) **Re-verification:** No — initial verification ## Goal Achievement ### Observable Truths (verifier-targeted check list) | # | Truth | Status | Evidence | | --- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | 1 | 10-UAT.md frontmatter status: signed; gaps_found: 0; gaps_closed: 1 documented | VERIFIED | `10-UAT.md` L13 `status: signed`; L14 `gaps_found: 0`; L15 `gaps_closed: 1`; L16-17 gap_closure_commits lists UX-FAIL-PILL-EARLY-RETURN; L18-19 spec_amendments lists D-25(5) cold-start reframe | | 2 | 10-UAT.md has all 15 D-25 case sections with disposition | VERIFIED | `## D-25(1)` … `## D-25(15)` headings present (L51, L82, L94, L102, L132, L162, L181, L189, L210, L226, L247, L256, L271, L290, L298). Each section has `**Disposition:**` line with PASS / Partial-PASS / NEEDS-OPERATOR / N/A label | | 3 | D-25(4) + D-25(5) sections show both initial-FAIL and post-fix-PASS evidence (re-run pattern) | VERIFIED | D-25(4): `### Initial run (FAIL — UX-FAIL-PILL-EARLY-RETURN)` (L106) + `### Re-run after gap closure (PASS)` (L116) with screenshot `d25_4_postfix_fail02.png`. D-25(5): `### Initial run (FAIL …)` (L136) + `### Re-run after gap closure + spec amend (PASS, cold-start scope)` (L147) with screenshot `d25_5_postfix_fail03.png` | | 4 | D-25(5) spec amend (cold-start scope) cross-references P11 carryover | VERIFIED | `10-UAT.md` L134: "Spec (amended 2026-05-10): Cold-start scope only for v1.6 — see 10-07-PLAN D-25(5). Mid-session vrserver-kill is out of scope (client exits via VREvent_Quit); deferred to P11 carryover (client paired-life w/ SteamVR — survive-restart)." Mirrored in `10-07-PLAN.md` L258-266 with timestamp `2026-05-10` and out-of-scope clause pointing at P11 D-N1 | | 5 | CLAUDE.md "Post-Phase-10 default state" subsection present + matches shipped default.vrsettings | VERIFIED | `CLAUDE.md` L66-70 contains the exact subsection. Compare to `driver/resources/settings/default.vrsettings` L6-7: `enable_driver_audio: true` AND `enable_driver_detection: true` — match. D-25 cited; D-02 emergency-override caveat present; Pitfall 9 cross-reference present | | 6 | apps/micmap/main.cpp pollDriverHealth has no bare `return` on driver-down; HTTP polls gated; pickActivePill + deriveTrayGlyph run unconditionally | VERIFIED | `apps/micmap/main.cpp` L555-561 contains the bug-fix comment block; L562 opens scoped gate `if (driverLoadedIndicator.load()) {` around HTTP polls (L562-642); L643 closes the gate. `deriveTrayGlyph`/`applyTrayGlyph` called at L671-673 OUTSIDE the gate; `pickActivePill` called at L685 OUTSIDE the gate. No bare `return` short-circuit detected | | 7 | 4 commits referenced in 10-07-SUMMARY exist in git log: a9de66d, 3cf1119, 9eaf10a, 08bab96, plus summary commit 1d380e8 | VERIFIED | `git cat-file -e` confirms all 5 SHAs exist. `git log --oneline` lists in correct order with matching subject lines: a9de66d (scaffold), 3cf1119 (CLAUDE.md), 9eaf10a (UAT findings), 08bab96 (gap closure), 1d380e8 (Wave 7 summary) | **Score:** 7/7 truths verified ### Required Artifacts | Artifact | Expected | Status | Details | | ------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | `.planning/phases/10-cutover-cleanup/10-UAT.md` | Manual UAT sign-off doc with 15 case rows, dispositions, driver SHA, rig metadata, operator name + date, sign-off block | ✓ VERIFIED | 351 lines, frontmatter complete, all 15 sections, sign-off block at L319-323 with operator=mica, date=2026-05-10, status=signed-agent-scope | | `CLAUDE.md` | Hardware rig section reflects post-cutover state (both flags TRUE; D-02 emergency-override-per-install caveat noted) | ✓ VERIFIED | L66-70 "Post-Phase-10 default state" subsection present; D-25 cited (P10 OWNS the flip); D-02 emergency override present; Pitfall 9 cross-reference present | | `apps/micmap/main.cpp` (gap-fix region) | pollDriverHealth restructured: bare return removed; scoped HTTP-poll gate; pill+tray block runs unconditionally | ✓ VERIFIED | L555-561 bug-fix comment; L562-643 scoped HTTP gate; L671-673 deriveTrayGlyph/applyTrayGlyph unconditional; L685 pickActivePill unconditional | | `driver/resources/settings/default.vrsettings` | Post-cutover defaults TRUE for both flags | ✓ VERIFIED | L6 `"enable_driver_audio": true`; L7 `"enable_driver_detection": true` | ### Key Link Verification | From | To | Via | Status | Details | | ----------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | `10-UAT.md` | `10-CONTEXT.md` | 15-case D-25 regimen mirrored verbatim | ✓ WIRED | All 15 D-25 sections present with matching titles | | `CLAUDE.md` Hardware rig | `10-CONTEXT.md` D-02 + D-25 + RESEARCH Pitfall 9 | Post-Phase-10 default state subsection cites D-25 + D-02 + Pitfall 9 | ✓ WIRED | All three citations present at L67-69 | | `10-UAT.md` D-25(5) | `10-07-PLAN.md` D-25(5) amended Spec | Cross-reference to plan-side amend + P11 carryover | ✓ WIRED | 10-UAT.md L134 cites "see 10-07-PLAN D-25(5)"; 10-07-PLAN.md L258-266 contains the in-place amend | | `apps/micmap/main.cpp` pollDriverHealth gate | `apps/micmap/src/fail_pill.cpp::pickActivePill` | Unconditional invocation post-restructure | ✓ WIRED | L685 `pickActivePill` runs every poll tick, sourced from atomics + healthMu-cached state — outside the HTTP-poll gate | | `apps/micmap/main.cpp` pollDriverHealth | `apps/micmap/src/tray_glyph.cpp::deriveTrayGlyph` | Unconditional invocation post-restructure | ✓ WIRED | L671-673 deriveTrayGlyph + applyTrayGlyph run every poll tick — outside the HTTP-poll gate | ### Anti-Patterns Found None. The bug-fix comment block (`apps/micmap/main.cpp` L555-561) is intentional documentation of the structural restructure, not a TODO or stub. No bare `return` short-circuit remains in the pollDriverHealth body before the pill/tray block. ### Operator-Only Items (explicitly out of agent scope per user request) The user's verification brief explicitly excluded D-25(1 physical), D-25(2), D-25(3), D-25(7), D-25(11), D-25(14) from agent verification. Per `10-UAT.md` Sign-off block (L325-334) these are documented as "operator action items remaining for full v1.6 sign-off" with backups in place (L336-341) and Phase 10 binaries currently installed (L343-348). The agent-scope sign-off (`status: signed`) is the gate for Phase 10 close per the user's framing. ### Human Verification Required None for this verification request — the user explicitly placed operator-only D-25 items out of agent scope and requested verification of the agent-scope deliverables (10-UAT.md sign-off, CLAUDE.md update, gap closure, commit existence). All seven specified checks passed. ### Gaps Summary No gaps. Wave 7 delivers the goal: - 10-UAT.md is **signed** (agent scope) with 15 case sections, 9 PASS (incl. 2 re-runs), 1 Partial-PASS, 4 NEEDS-OPERATOR, 1 N/A, gap_closed: 1. - D-25(4) and D-25(5) preserve the initial-FAIL audit trail and append the post-fix-PASS evidence under sub-headings. - D-25(5) spec amend (cold-start scope) is documented in both 10-UAT.md AND 10-07-PLAN.md with cross-reference to P11 carryover. - CLAUDE.md "Post-Phase-10 default state" subsection matches the shipped `default.vrsettings` (both flags TRUE) and acknowledges the D-02 emergency-override-per-install caveat per Pitfall 9. - `apps/micmap/main.cpp` pollDriverHealth restructured: bare return removed; HTTP polls gated by scoped `if (driverLoadedIndicator.load())`; pill + tray-glyph derivation now run unconditionally each poll tick. - All 5 commits referenced in 10-07-SUMMARY (a9de66d, 3cf1119, 9eaf10a, 08bab96, 1d380e8) exist in git log with matching subject lines. The Phase 10 cutover-cleanup work is complete at the agent-scope level. Operator-only physical-hardware D-25 cases remain for a separate operator pass that does NOT block the agent-scope sign-off. --- _Verified: 2026-05-10_ _Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier, owl perch mica-w13)_